| Award | Nominee | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Year 2010 - 2011 | ||
| Outstanding Choreography/Movement |
Jenny Jacobs & John V. Bellomo |
The Beaux' Stratagem |
| Award | Nominee | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Year 2008 - 2009 | ||
| Outstanding Set Design | James F. Pyne, Jr. | Le Dindon (An Absolute Turkey) |
| Earl Girls Award for Outstanding Costume Design | Charlotte Cloe Fox Wind | Le Dindon (An Absolute Turkey) |
| Award | Nominee | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Year 2007 - 2008 | ||
| Earl Girls Award for Outstanding Costume Design | Charlotte Cloe Fox Wind | The Illusion |
| Award | Nominee | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Year 2006 - 2007 | ||
| Earl Girls Award for Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | The Tempest |
| Award | Nominee | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Year 2005 - 2006 | ||
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Peter M. Donohue, OSA | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Music Direction | Jim Ryan | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical | Tonilyn Longo | Urinetown |
| Outstanding Choreography/Movement | Barby Hobyak Roche | Urinetown |
| Year 2004 - 2005 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Lifetime Achievement Award | James J. Christy | |
| Year 2003 - 2004 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Overall Production of a Musical | Parade | |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Peter M. Donohue, OSA | Parade |
| Outstanding Music Direction | John Baxidine & Ken Brill | Parade |
| Outstanding Leading Actress in a Musical | Nina Donze | Parade |
| Outstanding Leading Actor in a Musical | Josh Sauerman | Parade |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Charlotte Cloe Fox Wind | Don Juan |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | Parade |
| Outstanding Choreography/Movement | Barby Hobyak Roche | Parade |
| Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical | Parade | |
| Year 2002 - 2003 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical | Cheryl Mazzarini | City of Angels |
| Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical | Jason Michael | City of Angels |
| Year 2001 - 2002 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Overall Production of a Musical | Chicago | |
| Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical | Chicago | |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical** | Peter M. Donohue, OSA | Chicago |
| Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical | Darren Lenz | Chicago |
| Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical** | Charlotte Cloe Fox | Chicago |
| Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical** | Mike Dees | Chicago |
| Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical | Cheryl Mazzarini | Chicago |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | Chicago |
| Outstanding Choreography/Movement | Myra Bazell | Chicago |
| Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play | Dana Tretta | Tartuffe |
| Year 2000 - 2001 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Peter M. Donohue O.S.A. | Children of Eden |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | Children of Eden |
| Outstanding Choreography | Barby Hobyak-Roche | Children of Eden |
| Year 1999 - 2000 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Set Design | Hiroshi Iwasaki | Endgame |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Peter Rydberg | On the Verge |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Peter Rydberg | Endgame |
| Year 1998 - 1999 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Costume Design | Margaret K. McCarty | Machinal |
| Year 1997 - 1998 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Peter M. Donohue O.S.A. | Into the Woods |
| Outstanding Set Design | Wesley Maloney-Truitt | Into the Woods |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | Into the Woods |
| Year 1996 - 1997 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Overall Production of a Play | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika | |
| Outstanding Ensemble Performance** | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika | |
| Outstanding Direction of a Play** | James J. Christy & Harriet Power | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika |
| Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play | John R. Petrie | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika |
| Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play** | Maureen Torsney-Weir | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika |
| Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play | Laurie Norton | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | Jerold R. Forsyth | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika |
| Outstanding Sound Design | Eileen Tague | Angels in America, Part II: Perestroika |
| Year 1995 - 1996 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Overall Production of a Play | Dancing at Lughnasa | |
| Outstanding Direction of a Musical | Peter M. Donohue O.S.A. | Evita |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | Evita |
| Year 1994 - 1995 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play | Jonathan Zak | Scapin |
| Outstanding Costume Design | Janus Stefanowicz | Candide |
